VOLUME 19 (Supplement)

SciEnggJ%202026%20Special%20Issue%20265 280 Bautista%20et%20al

SciEnggJ 19 (Supplement) 408-417
available online: 12 November 2026
DOI: https://doi.org/10.54645/202619SupQZU-31

*Corresponding authorr
Email Address: debbratoria@ums.edu.my
Date received: 04 July 2026
Dates revised: 12 August 2026
Date accepted: 20 July 2026

ARTICLE

Economic and technological determinants of circularity: Panel data evidence from EU-27 member states

Debbra T. Nipo*1,2, Saizal Pinjaman1,2, Sing Y. Wong1,2, Jaratin Lily1, and Awangku H. B. Pengiran Bagul1

1Faculty of Business, Economics and Accountancy, University Malaysia Sabah, Kota Kinabalu 88400, Malaysia

2Centre for Economic Development and Policy, University Malaysia Sabah, Kota Kinabalu 88400, Malaysia

KEYWORDS: circular economy, panel data, resource productivity, circularity rate

To address growing resource constraints and the environmental problems of linear production and consumption, the transition to a circular economy has become a global priority for sustainability. The study examines whether resource productivity, fixed broadband subscriptions, research and development (R&D) expenditure, and employment in circular economy sectors are associated with the circular material use rate in the EU-27. The study estimated a fixed-effects panel model with country-clustered robust standard errors for 27 EU member states over 2014–2023 (270 observations). Resource productivity and fixed broadband subscriptions were positively and significantly associated with circularity, while R&D expenditure and employment in circular economy sectors were not statistically significant. The results suggest that resource-use efficiency and digital connectivity are associated with higher circularity, while the effects of R&D and circular-sector employment may depend on factors not captured in the model. The findings point to the relevance of resource efficiency and digital infrastructure for circularity policy.

© 2026 SciEnggJ
Philippine-American Academy of Science and Engineering